Spiga
Your Ad Here

Some Review of Asian Idol Perfomance, December 12, In PRJ

These reviews compiled from some forums toward Asian Idol performance in PRJ last time. And some reviews which good to hear is that Mike may have a big chance to win the Asian Idol Title, , according to their evaluation when the singing contest began on last December 12, 2007 at PRJ, Indonesia. Mike performance was totally wonderful -overall, compared by the other contestant by singing the song; Mengejar Matahari and I Believe I Can Fly. This show said to be aired on all contestant TV station on Saturday.

The Judges



Jaclyn Victor


Ata, Jaclyn, and Daniel


Mike Mohede


Phuong Vy


Hady Mirza


Abhijeet Sawant

Mau Marcelo


(L to R) Jaclyn, Phuong, Hady


Host : Ata, Daniel, Chen (Malaysia)
Selipan Host (Nirina, Indra Bekti)


Here are some reports and comments from them.

1st REVIEW by DP

Dear Idolerzzzz..

Last night i was in PRJ, seeing most spectacular show in Asia "ASIAN IDOL". Compare to World Idol, Asian Idol is wrapped much much better than World Idol, from the crowd, stage, lighting, music arrangement until voting system, but there was one thing i regret last night that Simon could not be there. I believe Simon's attendance would make the show more spectacular and of course he would give more tenses to the contestant, but unfortunately he was not there last night.

Anyway, I am so proud of Mike. He was dazzling last night. His angle's voice charmed almost all judges, no judge gave bad comment to him. I think his performance will make Indonesia proud of having him as Indonesian Idol. He had proofed that he is deserved to be Asian Idol. But you know what, I forget something, Oh Damn.. Asia also has another great Idol. She is Jaclyn. I never see her performance before, last night was my first time see her performance and i was totally amazed. So i think there will be a quite tight and major competition between Mike and Jac. I will give my vote for you two guys. MIKE and JAC.
Good luck both of you....

Last but not least, I am also proud of being Indonesian, Indonesia had proofed that Indonesia has capability to make great program with international standard. Hope there will be another big Indonesian made program broadcast across nations

2nd REVIEW by runejpunk

Prediksi and berita soal Lagu yang dibawain n Judgesnya ternyata tepat semua. Acaranya mulai kira2 mulai jam 9 Malem sampe jam 00.00.

Berikut review masing-masing konstestan dari penonton yang hadir saat konser berlangsung :

1. JACLYN VICTOR

Lagu Pertama :
Dibuka dengan penampilan Jacklyn dengan lagu baratnya (LUpa judulnya...lupa pula threadnya. dah cari2 ga ketemu).
Judges : Ok...but not the real jacklyn. (Indra) Ga seperti Jacklyn yang sudah saya denger suaranya. Kamu harus lebih baik di Lagu kedua. (Paul)Lumayan sebagai lagu pembuka. Kayanya km grogi ya??
Gue : Biasa aja. Ga dapet feel apa2.

Lagu kedua : Gemilang
Jacklyn mampu memperlihatkan apa yg dharapkan oleh juri. Rata2 Komentarnya positif. kec Ken Lim
Judges : (Paul) U make me Proud. Teknik Miking km sempurna. (Si-U) U'll be Famous as a singer. (Ken Lim) Ya km punya teknik dan punya kemampuan dengan high note km. Tapi agak standart karena udah ga sedikit org yg mempunyai nada tinggi kaya kamu.
Gue :
Hmm....awalnya di nada sedang, kedengeran klo Suara Jack rada cempreng. Emang cuma cocok di nada tinggi aja kali ya. High NOtenya Super Duper Oks.

2. HADY MIRZA

Lagu Pertama : Lagu Singapore
Dimulai dari tengah stage, dengan lagu yg agak2 melo. Secara keseluruhan Bagus tapi enggak Wah.
Judges : Good Performance, must be better in the next song
Gue : Biasa aja

Lagu kedua : Beautifull Life by U2
Judges : Km memang bener2 Good Performer and entertainer. (Indra) That Song suit2 You.
Gue : Lagi2 ga wah. ga dapet Feelnya. Mungkin karena Bagiannya Reffnya ga kedengeran.

3. PUONG VY

Lagu pertama : Ga tau judulnya
Ngebeat...dan lumayan dapet feelnya. Penonton banyak yg ikut goyang. Sepertinya penampilan terbaik hingga saat itu.
Judges : (Indra) That's a Boring Song. But U sang well, dan gw jadi menikmati. (Anu) Most impressive till Now.
Gue : menghibur
Lagu Kedua : Lagu Vietnam
Judges : I like the 1st song more. (Si-U)It's a good SONG....and U sang well, but it doesn't suit This Competition.
Gue : mbuh....Ga ngerti. Cuma merhatiin Pyong Vy yg caem aja

4. MAU MARCELO

Lagu pertama : Philippine Song
Tampil dengan baju khas filipina. Tampil dengan penuh percaya diri.
Judges : Oks banget. (Pilita Corrales ) Saya bangga km pakai baju khas Filipina. Penampilan kamu hebat. (Lim) Kalau untukl jadi penyanyi terkenal di Asia, paketnya harus kumplit. Outlook dan Voice. Suara km ga usah diragukan, tapi penampilan kamu......(Giru deh)
Gue : Emang bener powerfull banget suara Mau

Lagu Kedua : Reach by Gloria Estevan
Mau kelihatannya bener2 berusaha menampilkan kemampuan terbaiknya. Terbukti semua Juri suka dengan Mau. Sorry, komentarnya Ken Lim kurang Jelas.
Judges : (Kompakan) Stunning Performance.
Gue: Ada bagian2 yang kayanya maksa banget.

5. ABEZHIT SAWAN

Ternyata Ga sedikit ce2 yg kecantol sama si Abezhit ini. Malah sebagian Pendukung Hady banyak yg banting setir. Apalagi setelah penampilan kedua. Sayang...dah Merit (Atau baru ingin merit). Istrinya ikut menemani di bangku penonton.
Lagu pertama : Everything I do By Bryan Adams
Judges : Pilihan lagu yang bagus. sehingga penonton bisa ikut menikmati.
Gue : Hmmm bagian Reffnya, pelan banget suaranya jadi ga kedengeran. Atau memang ga sampai ya?? Bryan Adams kan memang Magic Voice, jadi emang rada sulit nyamain rangenya.
Lagu Kedua : Lagu India
Nah....Asyik banget nih lagu. Semua audience ikut goyang....Tarik Manggggg. O iya ada gaya selorotan khas Indianya pula. Nice Move.
Judges : (Anu) Km bikin India Bangga. Nanti km mesti jadi aktor juga. (Lainnya) U'r really Great Entertainer, walaupun suara km agak kurang tapi Tetap penampilan yang hebat.
Gue : Ikut Goyang.....Cape di suruh Foto-in dia melulu. Ce gw seneng banget ... . Hmmm....kalau dipikir Abezhit munkin cuma nyanyi 1/4 bagian Lagu aja.

6. MIKE MOHEDE

Wow.....mungkin kekhawatiran penonton Indonesia sebelum Mike tampil, serta pilihan lagu Mike terlalu berlebihan. Terbukti Mike mampu menggetarkan Seluruh Hall PRJ. Penampilannyapun Sangat meyakinkan.
Lagu Pertama : Mengejar Matahari
Sempet di Khawatirkan kurang greret, tapi ternyata semua itu berbalik jadi pujian. Mike dapet meng-ekplorer lagu ini dengan baik.
Judges : You Have Romantic Voice. (Indra) Seperti biasa Mike, Kamu bener2 Amazing. (Si-u) stunning. Salam cium jauh...CUPPP Muach.
Gue : Wew...Mike, thx buat penampilannya.
Lagu Kedua : I believe I can Fly by R Kelly
Lagu ter-akhir sekaligus penutup dr semua lagu yg dinyanyikan peserta.
Walau dah ketebak dari Awal, lagi2 Mike mampu memberikan yang terbaik dalam penampilannya.
Judges : (Anu) I LOVE Your Voice. (Indra) This is your very best Performance Off All. (Si-U) I believe U can Fly Mike. (Paul) I can't Imagine If Mike really Fly. Mike km harus bisa memanfaatkan lebar panggung. (Pilita Corrales ) walau dibilang penyanyi Asia harus punya Good Looking, Km akan sangat Cocok duet sama Mau. (Ken Lim) Setuju sama Om Paul.
Gue : Ga dapat terlukiskan dengan kata2. Apalagi pas Falseto Mike keluar. Megang Banget.

7. INDRA BEKTI (KONTESTAN "TAMBAHAN")
Jugdes : (Si-U) If U sing again, I Will Go. (yg lain) Mendingan jadi Dancer aja.
Gue : Wakakakakak...Gokil Abis

Ter-akhir ditutup dengan penampilan Medley semua Kontestan. Dari segi kualitas penampilan Kontestan gw akuin jempol semua. Kalau ada yg kurang greget, mungkin karena gw ga tau lagunya. Khususnya yg lagu daerah masing2. Yang pasti kalau menurut Gw setelah melihat Penampilan mereka semua (Mudah2an Objektif), Mike Pantes Jadi The 1st Asian Idol. Ya akan besaing abis dengan dengan Mau dan Jacklyn. Buat Hady n Pyong Vy, kayanya penampilannya masih sedikit kalah dibanding 3 org diatas. Abezhit....Oks banget Man. Ce gw aja suka.

Ok deh...thx semuanya, semoga Puas sama reviewnya. Klo jelek ya maklum amatiran dan dadakan.

Semoga dengan Review ini D'Jabz Bisa ngasih gw 2 ticket bir bisa nonton bareng lagi sama Ce Gw.
Thx All

3rd REVIEW by wantil

Performance Order At PRJ 12 December 2007

1st round: Jac - Hady - Phuong - Mau - Abhijeet - Mike
2nd round: Mau - Phuong - Hady - Jac - Abhijeet - Mike

Personal review ratings by this reviewer (out of 10) :

Jac 1st (english) - 8
Jac 2nd "gemilang" - 9.5

Hady 1st song (malay) - 7.5
Hady 2nd "beautiful day" - 8

Phuong 1st (english) - 8 (the ending is da' bomb)
Phuong 2nd (vietnamese) - 7.5

Mau 1st song (tagalog) - 8
Mau 2nd "reach" - 9

Abhijeet 1st "everything i do.." - 7.5
Abhijeet 2nd (indian) - 8

Mike 1st "mengejar matahari" - 8.5
Mike 2nd "i believe i can fly" - 8.5


Phiuuhh,, it's a tough one to pick who should win,
However, My top 3: Jac - Mau - Mike
Whoever wins, Asia got great talents

Get the Asian Idol free ticket at http://www.theasianidol.tv/freeticket.php




AddThis Social Bookmark Button



author : JH, NN

source :idolforum, indonesianidol



4 comment(s):

  Luke80

December 14, 2007 at 7:06 PM

I knew it ! finally bener juga, apa yang gua prediksikan tidak jauh2.. Mau and Jaclyn memang saingan terberat Mike. jadi gak sabar nunggu besok.. Go Mike !

  Dest4

December 15, 2007 at 11:54 AM

Gua yakin mike bisa menang di Asian Idol hari ini, walaupung Mau sama Jaclyn suaranya bagus bagus.... good luck my teddy bear ;b

  J H

December 15, 2007 at 12:32 PM

Gua baru baca berita kalau hari ini jam 1 siang ada ulasan roadshow to grand final, kayanya ini yang di PRJ...

  N N

December 15, 2007 at 3:19 PM

Bukan ternyata jeg, gua baru nonton, yang ditayangin cuma performa mike selama ini di ajang indonesian idol... maybe later today or tomorrow...

Related Posts with Thumbnails